Videos Teach Condition Facts Better than Doctors

Less facts but better mental care
provide visits with the doctor
© NCI Visuals Online

Researchers at the University of Michigan Health System have found that showing patients an educational video about their condition teaches them the facts about their disease even better than when their doctor tells them about the condition. But the power of videotaped information also has its limits. The scientists also found that anxiety and stress are reduced much more among patients after they have visited with their doctors than after viewing the information on the educational video.

"The study confirmed the informational value of videotape-based educational materials. In fact, patients learned many more facts from the videotape – which was created with information from physicians – than they learned from their doctors during a clinic visit," says lead author Jeffrey S. Orringer, M.D.

"We also expected that the educational videotape would reduce patients' anxiety and distress levels about their condition. It did, but their anxiety levels decreased by a much larger margin during clinic visits with their doctors," Orringer says. "This tells us that the videotape is an excellent educational tool, but that it can't replace a positive patient-doctor relationship."

Part of the reason the videotape was such a good educational tool, he says, is that the message was consistent. Patients could watch the tape over and over again, and the unchanging information was reinforced each time for the viewer. In contrast, an encounter with another human being is by its nature less consistent and redundant, Orringer points out.

At the same time, the consistency of the videotape helps to explain why it isn't as helpful at reducing a patient's distress and anxiety levels, he says. While the video is invariable, a doctor can tailor information to the specific concerns and fears a patient is encountering, says Orringer, clinical assistant professor of dermatology at the U-M Medical School and clinical director of the Cosmetic Dermatology and Laser Center at UMHS.

MEDICA.de; Source: University of Michigan Health System